Qatar’s Forced Labor Issues

The Gulf state of Qatar is known for being energy-rich, but also for its advanced levels of infrastructure that feature stunning skyscrapers and innovative architecture. Indeed, the Doha skyline dazzles, but underneath is a cruel reality. The state has long since relied on migrant labor to build these feats of construction and has been challenged by human rights organizations about harsh working conditions and unjust treatment of these immigrants. The United Nations’ International Labour Organization (ILO) has responded to complaints from Qatar’s migrant labor force over the years.

According to a recent article from Reuters, beleaguered workers have spoken out about “non-payment, late payment and/or reduction of agreed wages, passport confiscation, long hours of work…, the non-renewal of their identity cards by the employer and difficulty in transferring sponsorship.” Furthermore, workers live in unsanitary conditions where 10-12 people share a small room. A new report by Amnesty International, a group that has long been critical of Qatar’s labor practices, says that these deplorable conditions “amount to forced labor under international law.”

Unlike the practice of slavery, these are poor unskilled workers who seek out foreign labor markets in hopes of economic prosperity for their families back home. About 1.5 million migrants currently live and work in Qatar, making up 90% of the population. They are predominantly from India, Nepal, and Bangladesh. Most voluntarily make this choice to venture overseas, but they usually have no idea what they are getting themselves into. The State of Qatar repeatedly makes assurances of creating and enforcing new legislation to protect workers, but apart from ending the Kafala sponsorship system, not much has materialized. The ILO has now given Qatar a year to implement their planned reforms before launching an official investigation. I believe this allows Qatar to sidestep the issue for now and to continue to benefit from forced labor without any real repercussions. While the ILO cannot impose sanctions, others in the international community, like say the United States – a known ally of Qatar – can take action to pressure the state to address these unethical practices. While there is the concept of state sovereignty, I do believe that some countries have an obligation to question certain occurrences and help suffering human beings, no matter where they are.

With the 2022 FIFA World Cup to be held in Qatar, construction on new stadiums and facilities has intensified, prompting fresh allegations and investigations into the working conditions on the ground. FIFA, besieged with their own issues of internal corruption, which includes bribery in awarding the 2022 games to Qatar in the first place, seem to be largely indifferent to the matter. A potential prod into action would be if FIFA’s corporate sponsors pull their endorsements and investments. This will add more pressure to ensure that protective legislation is enacted and unjust working conditions are no longer in place.

The workers who spoke to Amnesty International anonymously in early 2015 called their situation “a living nightmare,” in which they are unable to leave the country, are threatened with withholding pay, and are told that there will be consequences if they don’t stay quiet. The Washington Post reported that 964 workers from India, Nepal, and Bangladesh died between 2012 and 2013. If the international community and world cup soccer sponsors do not put pressure on Qatar and FIFA, these practices will flourish and Qatar will continue to build its glittering prestige upon a new form of slavery.

cocafifa

Coca-Cola is one of FIFA’s major sponsors.

 

 

 

 

Preoccupation with the Veil

In February 2015, The Washington Post reported that a Muslim woman in Quebec, Canada was not allowed to bring her case to the courtroom until she removed her hijab, the head scarf which denoted her religion. The judge considered the hijab an inappropriate item of clothing for a court proceeding, akin to hats and sunglasses, and barred the woman from having her day. “I will not hear you, I have to apply the same rules to everybody,” the judge said.

But the same rules do not apply to everybody. Hats or sunglasses do not carry the same weight of modesty or religious piety that is associated with the head scarf for many women, and it is not taken off and on with such frequency. Furthermore, as noted in the article,  Jewish individuals who wear a yarmulke have been allowed in the court. So why the fuss over the hijab? The veil has become a symbol of Islam, for better and mostly for worse. In the present climate of fundamentalism and political violence, there is a prevalent stereotype equating all Muslims with terrorists, or that there is some kind of guilt by religious association. Thus, in some areas, anything denoting a person’s affiliation to Islam is met with intolerance and fear. One can argue that the Canadian judge did not want to entertain a connection to terrorism in her courtroom. However, the judge’s unfair assessment was discriminatory and hurtful. The Muslim woman said, “I felt like she was talking with me as … not a human being.”

Apart from the recent stereotype, non-Islamic cultures often view the hijab, or other form of covering, like the niqab or burqa, as an antiquated form of oppression. They see it as a way for Muslim men to control and repress the identities of women by not allowing them this physical freedom of expression. It is legally required in countries like Saudi Arabia and Iran – two states directly governed by Islamic law. However, the Quran does not explicitly say that women should wear any specific form of covering. It stipulates that both men and women must wear modest clothing in public, however it is not specified what ‘modest’ is, or from what age or in which fashion one practices modesty. This is largely open to interpretation and the reasons vary greatly by location and from woman to woman. Laws aside, women may choose to don the hijab, niqab, or burqa for very various, personal reasons – indeed, they might wear it to show religious piety, to deter unwanted attention, or even for temperature regulation (“International Studies”, p. 446).

In regards to those Muslim women who freely choose to cover up, one might argue the case of internalized oppression through tradition and socially taught ideologies. But regardless of the individual reasons for covering up, Muslim and non-Muslim women are often judged harshly or discriminated against when they do appear in public in a hijab or other covering. In October 2015, there was a kerfuffle over an ad for presidential candidate Hillary Clinton in which she is shown wearing a head scarf during a trip to Pakistan in 2009. A critic said, “In odd contrast to touting Hillary’s feminism and strength, is this shot of her wearing a Hijab; an Islamic garment of submission… [and] is advertising that she is the property of a man…”

While submission to God is inherent in being Muslim, submission to man is not necessarily the reason why women (of any background or religion) choose to cover themselves. In this case, Clinton appears to be showing “diplomatic courtesy” and respect for the foreign culture, and it was yet another unfair assessment to assume that by merely covering her head in this setting that Clinton was being submissive or oppressed in any way. In short, women may or may not cover up for a variety of reasons, and we cannot presume to know them all. We must be open-minded and tolerant of the choices of others, and we must educate ourselves before jumping to conclusions and engaging in prejudiced or discriminatory acts.
Moreover, one should take a step back and assess the issue within the perspective of the real atrocities and tragic acts of violence happening in the world right now. The question then arises: why are we so preoccupied with the veil?

 

A Change of Tide for Cuba?

7-casablanca-quotes

The last scene of “Casablanca” – 1942

President Obama, his wife Michelle, and their two daughters are in Havana, Cuba this week – a historic visit that is facilitated by the warming of relations between the United States and Cuba that occurred back in December 2014. In a piece for The Brookings Institution, Richard Feinberg shares the implications of this trip for the Cuban people, which point to some critical changes that could arise on the island. Feinberg writes that Cubans have looked to the Obamas’ visit with mixed feelings. On one hand,  some are apprehensive about the looming influence of “the Colossus from the North,” while others see this influence in a positive light. Most Cubans welcome the emergence of a good relationship with the most powerful country in the world. It brings the potential for more open trade, access to American goods, tourists, and of course, their own ability to travel freely off the island. Other citizens are more concerned about the potential for a liberal society, where they can gather and freely express their opinions. What this all points to is the contention of democracy vs. communism (yet again).

Latin America has had a tumultuous relationship with democracy, but there have been some successes after World War II. Critics today feel like Cuba is not moving in any way towards a liberal democracy, however, we can examine a few sources for democracy* in the present climate to see if there is a potential foothold on the island state. First, there is modernization. Cuba is in dire straights owing to a variety of limitations, such as the state’s dependence on oil from Venezuela, restrictions on citizens creating businesses and forming trading relationships, and limited access to the outside world via poor internet connectivity. The gross national income per capita is only about $5,500. The theory states that as a country gets more modern, it tends to get more democratic, owing to higher education levels, a relaxing of older institutions, and the rise of a middle class, among other things. It seems Cuba will have a long way to go for this source to materialize in any significant way.

Another source is the elites in charge. Feinberg asserts that, “[Raul] Castro presumably wants to see his Communist Party retain its grip on power,” so perhaps that source is not so likely either. Society and culture might be the strongest areas. Feinberg notes, “Some [Cubans] are even forming proto-civil society groupings, to advance gender equality, environmental stewardship, religious freedom, and human rights.” When there is an outlet for civil society and the sharing and promotion of ideas, people feel the need to have a voice in the political process to better represent their interests. The last area where democracy might have a chance is through international relations. This is happening right now as President Obama shines a spotlight on the country during his historic visit.

Whether there is a regime change in Cuba given the changing atmosphere between it and the U.S. is to be seen, but Feinberg brings up a good point that their respective successors are the ones to determine the outcome of this new relationship.

* As outlined in “Essentials of Comparative Politics,” by Patrick O’Neil

Russia leaves Syria; Assad Should Go Next

In September 2015, Russia’s decision to militarily intervene in the Syrian civil war raised many eyebrows and added a few more wrinkles to already beleaguered politicians, like U.S. President Obama and Turkey’s President Erdogan. This week, Putin’s announcement that Russian troops will cease fire and withdraw from Syria triggered surprise yet again. Many are still wondering about Putin’s true motives and intentions for the regime of Syrian President Bashar al-Assad, who triggered this entire conflict back in 2011.

Though this six-month Russian engagement is the latest event in the five-year war that has been going on in the region, Russia believes it has largely achieved its objective and made progress towards an end to the conflict. Here, a grandiose quote from President Putin: “The effective work of our military created the conditions for the start of the peace process. I believe that the task put before the defence ministry and Russian armed forces has, on the whole, been fulfilled. With the participation of the Russian military … the Syrian armed forces and patriotic Syrian forces have been able to achieve a fundamental turnaround in the fight against international terrorism and have taken the initiative in almost all respects.”

Many would question this, pointing out that Russia has instead targeted rebels and opposition groups backed by the West, endangered thousands of civilians in the process, and further showed blatant encouragement of the Assad government. However, Putin has now taken a step back to allow peace talks to resume in Geneva, Switzerland. By withdrawing, Putin is in agreement with President Obama that there needs to be a political resolution in Syria, not a military one. So, the important point in the negotiations seems to be whether Assad will stay or go. I am aware of multiple sources driving this conflict, but it seems clear that this one man (and his regime) is the fuel that ignited the fire in the first place. According to the BBC, since coming into power in 2000, Assad has stifled all utterances of democracy and eliminated freedom of the press, among others. His treatment of dissident citizens has been unduly harsh, including the use of chemical weapons in the ongoing conflict. After holding onto power for about 16 years now, I believe it is time for Assad to exit.

My main reason is the humanitarian aspect. While Assad has clearly demonstrated that states have the monopoly on violence, I believe states should also be responsible for the well-being of their citizens, and utilize this violence towards their protection, not their punishment. Since the conflict started, about 4.5 million people have fled the country, another 6.5 million are internally displaced, about 70% do not have access to clean water, and 80% of citizens currently live in poverty.

I believe Assad should not be allowed to continue his reign at the expense of so many lives, and the future of Syrian children. Too long have the Syrian people suffered under these atrocious conditions, essentially being punished for doing nothing wrong. My hope is that these peace talks result in Assad’s removal from office, at the least. After this, I would hope to see a transition to a legitimately democratic system. Though, I am also aware that, since the time of European colonialism, new governments in the Middle East often have a hard time finding sure footing, which may lead to even more chaos and strife to come.

 

 

 

How Factory Jobs Help Bangladeshi Women

According to a September 2014 research brief from The Cato Institute, “Access to factory jobs significantly lowers the risk of early marriage and childbirth for girls in Bangladesh, and this is due to both girls postponing marriage to work in factories and to girls staying in school at earlier ages.” Despite the documented dangers and harsh working conditions of garment factories in developing countries, the authors explain that the increase of such jobs in Bangladesh has had a profound effect on young women in the areas of education, marriage, and childbirth. These jobs require a decent level of numeracy and literacy and thus, girls stay in school longer to learn as much as they can to go after these jobs. With this, comes a higher level of education and a delay of marriage.

As I’m also taking a class in the Upheavals of War, I am reminded of the vast redefinition of gender roles during World Wars I and II, when women gained newfound freedoms and responsibilities outside of just being wives and mothers. As all of the young and able-bodied men were sent off to fight, women kept calm, carried on, and took up the jobs necessary to the functioning of daily life. Work needed to be done, whether on the farms or in the factories, and only women were left to do it. Women were eager to assume these roles – wanting to contribute to the national war effort and also, to gain a kind of independence and respect outside the home that they had never experienced before.

Life for European and North American women changed as they saw themselves capable of achieving more than domesticity during this time, and they seized the opportunity. In present day, women around the world still struggle to escape the disadvantages of their gender; particularly in South Asia, where child marriage is still prevalent.

A report I came across by Human Rights Watch states that “Bangladesh has the fourth-highest rate of child marriage in the world,” where about 65 percent of girls are married before age 18. Child marriage is usually bred out of economic poverty and perpetuates it, along with other ills such as spousal abuse and the increased likelihood of death in childbirth. Along with these, I add the noted cultural stigma of being viewed as “less than” if not married by a certain age. However, in Bangladesh and other impoverished nations, this age is much lower than in the West, resulting in dire circumstances for very young girls. Bangladeshi girls are beholden to this cultural practice and are made to accept their fate, despite not being mentally or physically ready for married life. Additionally, most are forced to cast away their hopes of attending or continuing school. I can relate to this in a way. At 19, I was pressed to consider an arranged marriage because I was not able to move on to college after graduating high school. I protested and declined, and eventually ended up working for several years before being able to attend college. I was able to hold on and wait for my higher education opportunity, but not many disadvantaged women get to do this.

As the research states, there is a correlation between higher educational attainment and the postponement of marriage. I believe that if impoverished women can stay in school longer, and later, acquire jobs to sustain themselves, they are seen as less of a burden upon their families in terms of finances and protection. Like wartime jobs in Europe and North America, the garment industry in Bangladesh is providing a means of independence and security that these girls have never experienced, and might prove to be the key to the advancement of women in this particular region.

 

 

The Necessary Resources for A Normal Life

Life for the citizens of Krasnodar, Russia is grim.

I knew peripherally that Russia was not doing well economically, but I was not aware of the on-the-ground details. For The New York Times, Neil MacFarquhar unfolds the dire economic straits in Krasnodar, a small southern region, and he paints a startling picture. Citizens have been affected by a decrease of transportation subsidies that restrict their travel on local trolleys. Workers in a machine tool factory have not been paid in a year. Food prices rose by 20%, making items such as apples, zucchini, and smoked sausages too expensive for some. People are not using as much heating and electricity at home, and are not rushing out to buy new clothes or cars.

Sergei Titov, a resident of Krasnodar, assesses the situation: “It is clear that the government lacks the necessary resources to give us a normal life.”

Blame it on the oil and the oligarchy
So what are the major causes? President Putin had reassured citizens that the economy was going to jump back any minute now, and that this presented a chance for the country to diversify away from oil. The present era of cheap oil hurts a number of nations, and Russia is not exempt – 50% of its federal budget is dependent on energy exports. However, when the price of a barrel of oil dropped to $30 at the beginning of 2016, the value of the Russian ruble plummeted and massive inflation occurred. MacFarquhar writes, “The last time oil prices dropped so low and stayed there, in the 1980s, the Soviet Union disintegrated.”

23RUSSIA-master675

Russian workers protesting lack of wages outside of Sbarro – Photo by James Hill for The New York Times.

Indeed, the outlook of the Russian economy seems to hearken back to deplorable Soviet-era conditions, and the current version of the nomenklatura is at play. In Moscow, truckers recently protested increased tolls and fees which will result from the implementation of a new GPS tracking system. The system is partly owned by Igor Rotenberg, a billionaire whose family is close with Putin. Other claims have been made about Moscow’s elite enjoying fancier food items at their parties while the rest of the country labors without pay and spends double on regular food items. MacFarquhar also writes about employees at a Moscow Sbarro protesting their months-long lack of wages. I find this an interesting highlight of globalization – the expansion of communication and market connections, and social and political interdependence. Sbarro is an American-owned Italian restaurant chain based in Columbus, Ohio.

So will Putin’s reign disintegrate as well? I think not, but it would be interesting if an Arab Spring-like phenomenon occurs in the country. Putin’s current actions on the international stage, involving Ukraine, Crimea, and Syria, and his focus on prestige projects like the Olympics and the forthcoming World Cup point to his disregard of internal issues and his people’s well-being. These are major facets of everyday life currently under siege by the economic depression, and while citizens are coming out in numbers to protest (on the streets and on social media), it remains to be seen if this escalates in another class struggle, and creates any kind of political impact that threatens Putin.

 

 

Russia Irks the Turks

As previously discussed, Russia’s foray into the Syrian conflict near the end of 2015 has added a new dimension to the crisis that will yet prove its worth. While Russia is supposedly committed to the fight against the Islamic State (IS), I believe this might also be an insidious power play by Putin to alter the international playing field towards his advantage. Nevertheless, Russia’s involvement and strategy in Syria has clearly irked many of its international neighbors and rivals, with tensions escalating in November 2015 when “Turkish jets shot down a Russian fighter-bomber near the Syrian border, the first hostilities between Russia and a NATO member since the end of the cold war,” according to The Economist.

For its part, Turkey said that the bomber was warned several times to leave the airspace before fire was opened. However, I think this just adds to Turkey’s list of frustrations with Russia, which includes Putin’s unwavering support for Syrian president Bashar al-Assad and the encouragement of the separatist Kurds within Turkey itself.

The Kurdish people are spread out in regions of Iraq, Iran, Syria and Turkey, and owing to their distinct ethnic identity and culture have long wanted their autonomy and self-rule. The Kurds have different cultural practices, cultural logics, and naturally, different worldviews from the dominant Turks and feel that they deserve their own sovereign nation apart from the state of Turkey. I find one area of contention to be particularly appalling: the Turkish government has denied the use of the Kurdish language in schools. In the view of anthropologists, language and accents can be considered the embodiment of a culture – something that is completely natural and hard to change. To be denied this is essentially suppressing a critical part of enculturation for future generations. I feel that this is quite unreasonable as they constitute the largest ethnic minority group in Turkey. So since last summer, they have been engaged in a civil war with the Turkish military in the country’s southeast region. Russia has long supported the Kurdish movement for its own state.

Apart from this, and what led to Turkey striking down the Russian bomber, is the fact that Russia targeted Syrian villages with Turkish populations. It appears to me that these two states are engaged in a tussle, the effects of which are already manifesting, and might have implications in other non-military sectors. For example, Turkey is dependent on Russia for 20% of its energy supply. I believe, given the tension, Turkey might re-evaluate these energy transactions going forward. Furthermore, tourism has taken a blow due to Russia blocking vacation packages to Turkey – Istanbul being a popular spot for relaxing Russians.

Again, this calls into question Russia’s end game regarding the Syrian war – its involvement thus far has primarily served to irritate other states in the region. Though it seems Turkey has no interest in directly engaging with Russia militarily, they no doubt have to contend with its dubious motives regarding Syria and the Kurds.

Istanbul-40938

A view of Istanbul, Turkey – a popular tourist destination

 

Russia – Flexing Its Global Muscle

The present foreign policy of Russia seems to be about flexing its global muscle once again in a world dominated by stronger powers. Evidence of this can be found in its recent decision to get involved in the crisis in Syria, as Angela Stent explains in the Jan/Feb 2016 issue of Foreign Affairs Magazine. I agree that this move, along with Russia’s recent maneuvers in Ukraine and the annexation of Crimea, has sent a clear message that the country, under the leadership of Vladimir Putin, is eager to sit at the adults’ table for the feast of international power. I find similarities with Germany in World War I, who also wanted to show off its might and capacity to be a major world player.

Pertaining to Geographic Location
At the onset of World War I, the German territory’s relative location was right in the middle of the European continent, between France and Russia. Germany stared down the reality of fighting a war on two separate fronts. I have always viewed Russia as belonging to two geographic regions – Europe and Asia. Already involved in precarious conflicts in Ukraine and Crimea, Russia now seeks to engage on another front, so to speak, by intervening in the Middle East. With this foray, Russia may be exerting its grasp and influence in a third region.

 

 

Pertaining to Motive
Germany gave Austria-Hungry a “blank check” of support in 1914, but had its own personal reasons for instigating a large-scale conflict. According to Stent, Russia’s official reason for entering the Middle Eastern conflict is to combat terrorists of the Islamic State of Iraq and the Levant (ISIL), and to curb the number of Syrian refugees fleeing to Europe and other nations. However, as noted on the map, Russian airstrikes have primarily targeted Syrian rebels instead, some of whom fight on the side of America and its Arab allies, namely Saudi Arabia and Qatar. If Russia plans to gain influence in the Middle Eastern region, I am not sure that getting on the bad side of two Persian Gulf giants is a good idea. Additionally, Russia has been struggling economically as of late. I would think that maintaining a solid relationship with such wealthy and influential Arab states would increase investments and financial backing that could potentially help the economy and the Russian citizens.

I draw comparisons to Germany in The Great War because of what appears to be the same eagerness to prove its power and influence in the international arena. With the recent military involvement in Syria, I see Russia as making similar moves, which hopefully will not escalate to World War proportions.